Families of murder victims gathered at a press conference hosted by the Orange County District Attorney to denounce Governor Newsom's recent constitutional decision. The governor announced the modification of death sentences for 548 incarcerated individuals convicted of capital offenses. Steve Herr, whose son Pfc. Samuel Eliezer Herr was shot and killed by a neighbor in Costa Mesa in 2010, spoke strongly against the commutation. Herr reminded attendees that Californians previously voted to keep the death penalty. In 2016, Proposition 62 failed to pass, with roughly 53 percent of voters opposing the replacement of capital punishment with life imprisonment.
Orange County District Attorney Todd Spitzer expressed skepticism regarding the long term safety of the commutation. He highlighted that individuals sentenced to life without parole occasionally secure resentencing under specific circumstances. Following the November 5 announcement, the California Board of Parole Hearings issued an update clarifying that inmates receiving Newsom's commutation are strictly excluded from eligibility under recent regulations established in October. Newsom maintained that the commuted offenders will remain incarcerated until death, describing it as the most severe punishment the state can ethically enforce.
California has executed 13 individuals since 1978, with the last execution occurring in January 2006. The process has cost taxpayers an estimated $6 billion. Despite the moratorium on executions and the closure of the execution chamber implemented by Newsom in 2019, the state maintains the largest death row population in the country. Six inmates were exonerated between 1989 and the present based on evidence proving their innocence. Newsom cited the risk of convicting innocent people and the incompatibility of state sanctioned killing with California values as primary reasons for the decision.
The press conference underscored the localized impact of statewide judicial changes. DA Spitzer, who served as a witness during the final California execution in 2006, characterized the blanket commutation as absolute nonsense. He warned that similar sentences historically resulted in eventual releases. Meanwhile, Governor elect Xavier Becerra, who assumes office in January 2027, has signaled his intent to maintain the current moratorium on state sanctioned executions.